Choosing the best breast pump can be sometimes challenging to say the least. It’s much like choosing between a chocolate and an ice-cream. Both are delicious.
Our #1 Recommended Hospital Grade Pump:
Ameda Mya Portable Hospital Strength Breast Pump
Which one is better? Why should you choose only the best one? What are the differences?
This article will help you to decide. Let’s put hospital grade pump vs pump in style on a scale and find the best one. But before then, let me address a few questions you might have in mind:
Is Medela Pump In Style a Hospital Grade pump?
No, the Medela Pump In Style is not primarily a hospital grade pump. It’s one of the most used personal pumps but it can deliver hospital-level performance for nursing mothers.
Is a hospital grade pump better?
Choosing the right breast pump can be difficult at times. Most times, a hospital grade pump is recommended because it’s equipped with ‘closed system’ capabilities.
Thus, it prevents milk and other fluids getting into the motor, which, in turn, reduces contamination of all sorts and makes it safer and convenient for multiple users.
Which hospital grade pump is better?
There are so many factors to consider when buying a hospital grade pump. But if you would rather go for the best, most breastfeeding moms recommend the medela Symphony Breast Pump on Amazon.
What makes a pump hospital grade?
A pump qualifies as hospital grade if it’s designed for multiple users over a period time. If you’re tight on budget or wants to pump for a few months, you’d save some money when you rent a hospital grade pump instead of buying a personal one like the Pump In Style.
With these important questions out of the way, let’s compare the features of Hospital grade pump and Pump In Style:
Hospital grade pump key features
Many women believe that the hospital grade pump is better to increase supply. According to surveys, it is true.
Hospital grade pump increases milk production to a considerable supply.
This holds powerful pump performance with the maximum suction strength of 280 mmHg and drains milk as much as possible.
This Hospital-approved pump comes with a closed system which offers backflow protection, preventing contamination and infections.
It can be used as a single or double pump — also providing facility to easily control the speed and rhythm which is favorable to your body and your physique.
Usually, this pump does not come with a battery. They are not portable and you cannot haul with you wherever you go.
They are large and costly. A typical hospital grade pump bears a price tag of $1,500.
What makes the hospital grade pump better?
- Hospital grade pump is quick; it takes about 5-10 minutes for a full drain.
- It has a separate control for suction and speed. You can adjust speed and suction rhythm separately. While keeping the speed constant you can enhance suction and vice versa.
- It drains more milk than any other pump present in the market. It is not jerky and much gentler on the nipples making it more comfortable if you have sore nipples.
- This can help you to settle the supply. Its powerful suction capability settles the milk drainage to its maximum swing.
- They are super quiet and you would have a quiet pumping experience.
Pump in Style key features
Pump in style usually comes with a bag that holds an ice bag and bottles that can fit into a cooler.
Hence, they can provide a temporary storage capacity.
Pump in Style breast pump comes with an AA or rechargeable battery and are portable.
They also hold car chargers and can be great for traveling or tours.
The pump in style has two phase expression technology and holds top touch let-down button. They have LCDs and button penal.
They weigh as heavy as four apples only, nicely shaped, and portable. All their parts are BPA free that touch breast milk.
What makes the pump in style better?
- The microfiber bag makes sure all the pump parts are kept together. It offers mental piece so you don’t find yourself missing a part when you want to use it.
- The cooler gives you the comfort of mind when you are at work. It allows you to drain the milk and store.
- Ice bag prevents the breast milk from spoiling as long as mom returns back to home and put it in the refrigerator.
- It comes with a lot of nice-to-haves, including breast shields, valves, membrane, and tubing, etc.
What do hospital grade and pump in style have common?
Despite having a lot of differences, it’s good to know that both pumps have some common characteristics. Actually, these common traits are the features that are crucially demanded by the consumers.
Let’s see what they both have in common:
- They both have double suction pumps and you have an option to use single as well.
- They both are electric and not manual.
- Both pumps are easy to wash and offer a convenient structure to be cleaned up completely preventing the vessels from contamination.
- The hospital grade pump and the pump in style both have the option to control suction and speed of the pump. This helps keep the cycle of your pumping session more personalized.
What makes them different?
It makes sense to also mention the difference between hospital grade pump and the pump in style. They are as follows:
Open vs closed system
One of the main differences between these pumps is that the hospital grade pump has a closed system but the pump in style usually comes with an open system.
The open and closed system means that the pump with the closed system has a certain structure that prevents the milk from entering into the suction tubes or motors of the pump.
However, the open system lacks barriers which stop milk from entering into the tubes and motors.
Obviously, hospital grade pump is far better than the pump in style in this sense. In an open system, contamination is anticipated.
Hospital grade models do not have a rechargeable battery and also not support an AA battery pack. They are not portable. They require an uninterrupted electric supply.
Pumps in style are portable and have built-in rechargeable batteries. Some pumps support an AA battery making them more convenient to carry.
Hospital grade models come with a label of more powerful suction feature and do not disappoint. Women usually like the hospital pump due to its great suction ability, powerful expression, and more drain.
This pump boasts the maximum suction strength of 280 mmHg and even more. This feature enables them to extract more milk.
On the other hand, pump in style does not have that suction strength. These pumps have maximum 250 mmHg suction strength.
Although both pumps allow you to control set their speed and suction power accordingly, yet, they have some basic differences.
The Hospital model has timers that are really helpful alongside digital control panel.
They have buttons to set a timer, speed, and suction strength, etc. LCD screen also has a backlight enabling it to be visible even I darker.
Pump in style bears dials. You need to turn the dial and set speed and strength. They do not have timers and LCD screens.
The noise of the pump
Neither the hospital grade nor the pump in style is extremely quiet. They both make more or less noise while working.
However, the hospital grade pump has less noise compared to the pump in style.
The stylish pump comes with a lot more accessories. A typical “style” package includes all the pump parts, extra bottles, cooler, ice pack, and a bag.
PISA pumps have all accessories enclosed in a package. Medela also throws some extra parts a guidelines manual that sets all to start immediately.
However, the PISA does not have a good tote bag and rattle the storage bottles while carrying. You will feel it essential to replace its tote bag with a good one.
Medela has nice bags that contoured ice bag fitting properly around the storage bottles. It is a really nice thing to have.
Hospital grade pumps are costly and their parts are not easily available in markets. You need to find and purchase them online.
However, parts and accessories of the pump in style are available in common stores and online as well. this makes them more convenient to purchase.
Who is the winner?
Both of these pumps have top-notch quality and will appeal to moms all over the world.
However, it all depends on the user’s need, circumstances, and comfort.
Here’s the difference: Pump in style is more suitable for the working moms because it offers more portability and easy handling. And hospital grade pump is suitable for the moms who want to pump milk as quickly as possible.
In the end, they are both great pumps. Though I’d say the hospital grade pump is a better option. I actually like the Lansinoh Smartpump with Bluetooth on Amazon.
The combination of suction strength, digital control, higher efficiency, and durability gives a slight advantage over the pump in style.